Milena Hoeg
student
Technische Hochschule Augsburg
Germany
Architektura
The Klinikum Memmingen, a hospital complex built in 1955 and expanded to 18 building components by 2016, is set to relocate by 2029. The 43,700 m² inner-city… more
Omar Harb
advisor
USEK - Holy spirit University of Kaslik
Lebanon
As an architect and founder of Omar Harb Architects & Associates, my work centers on creating… more
The project presents an architectural proposal that seeks to establish a balance between formal expression and functional organization. The submission reflects a clear intent to articulate a coherent design language while addressing programmatic requirements within a structured spatial framework. The overall composition demonstrates an awareness of architectural order and an effort to maintain consistency across different scales.
A key strength of the project lies in its attempt to reconcile expressive form with usability. The design suggests a deliberate exploration of geometry and spatial articulation, contributing to a recognizable architectural identity. In several instances, the project indicates an understanding of how form can influence spatial experience and user interaction.
However, the relationship between architectural expression and performance remains only partially resolved. While the formal strategy is evident, it is not always supported by a corresponding level of functional clarity or environmental responsiveness. Certain elements appear driven primarily by compositional intent rather than by spatial necessity or performance criteria.
Additionally, the project would benefit from a more integrated approach to context. The current proposal tends to prioritize internal logic over external conditions, resulting in a limited dialogue with site-specific factors such as climate, orientation, and surrounding environment.
Overall, the project demonstrates a controlled and expressive design approach. With further development in functional integration, environmental performance, and contextual grounding, it has the potential to evolve into a more cohesive and resilient architectural proposal.
1. Align Expression with Performance
Ensure that formal decisions are supported by:
functional requirements
spatial efficiency
environmental logic
Architectural expression should emerge from performance, not operate independently of it.
2. Strengthen Functional Integration
Refine how spaces operate:
clarify program distribution
improve adjacencies
ensure usability aligns with spatial intent
3. Enhance Environmental Responsiveness
Integrate passive strategies into the design:
orientation and solar control
natural ventilation
shading systems as part of the architectural language
4. Refine Spatial Hierarchy
Clarify the relationship between:
primary vs secondary spaces
open vs enclosed areas
public vs private zones
This will improve both legibility and user experience.
5. Develop Contextual Dialogue
Anchor the project within its environment:
respond to site conditions
engage with landscape or urban context
avoid autonomy detached from surroundings
6. Improve Analytical Representation
Strengthen the clarity of the proposal through:
diagrams linking form to function
environmental performance illustrations
clearer sections demonstrating spatial quality
The project demonstrates a strong expressive intent; further alignment between form, function, and environmental performance will significantly enhance its architectural coherence and effectiveness.
15.04.2026