Amina Adawy, Maram Ahmed, Amira Al-Karmoty, Nour Ghoraba, Yara El-Sayed
student
The American University in Cairo
Egypt
Architecture
Memoria Viva transforms the former Miguel de Azcuénaga Arsenal into a living memorial where remembrance becomes an active civic experience. Rather than… more
Arbresha Ibrahimi
advisor
International Balkan University
Macedonia
My architectural focus lies in museum architecture, with a strong interest in the social and… more
It is very true that memory is a driving force, and this argument constitutes a sufficient and highly important starting point to be addressed and considered within the context of architectural design. You have approached the project exceptionally well in terms of analysis, and it has been elaborated in a very clear and detailed manner, starting from the initial idea and objectives to the social, natural, and built environment analyses. The visual and functional connectivity of the buildings is in complete harmony with nature and, moreover, with your design vision. The graphic presentation is particularly impressive. The connection of memory with brutalism, albeit through a refined interpretation of brutalism, creates space for perception to be regenerated through memory. A particularly strong element of the project is the fact that you do not treat memory as a single symbol, nor do you attempt to imitate it visually. In such cases, there is usually little room left for further development, whether of the buildings, the landscape, or the community. You have addressed this aspect exceptionally well.
My suggestions are mainly related to the presentation of the floor plans. Try to incorporate all the necessary furnishing elements within each space, as this will significantly help you understand the functionality of the interior spaces, that is, the very "soul" of the space. Additionally, in public buildings, all entrances should open outward, that is, towards the exterior, since in emergency situations the evacuation of people is facilitated.
Congratulations on your work and dedication.
03.07.2026
Dear Dr Arbresha Ibrahimi,
I hope you are doing well.
On behalf of our team, I would like to sincerely thank you for taking the time to review our project and share your valuable feedback with us. We truly appreciate the care and effort you put into evaluating our work and offering thoughtful suggestions to help us improve our plans.
Your comments were incredibly helpful and gave us a clearer understanding of areas we can develop further. As architecture studens, receiving constructive feedback from someone with your experience is something we genuinely value, and we are grateful that you took the time to guide us.
We are always eager to learn and grow, and we would be honored to continue learning from you if the opportunity ever arises. If you are ever available for a conversation or have any additional thoughts on our project, we would sincerely appreciate the chance to hear them.
Thank you once again for your generosity, encouragement, and willingness to share your expertise. It was a privilege to present our work to you, and we hope to stay in touch and continue learning from you in the future.
With sincere gratitude,
Amina Adawy
On behalf of the Memoria Viva team