inci SHOAINIA

advisor

Gazi University, Faculty of Architecture, Ankara

Turkey

İnci Shoainia is an architect and co-founder of Spika Architecture, based in Turkey. She holds a… more

The project's relationship with nature is quite successful and impressive. The sloping, grass-covered roof of the structure acts as a continuation of the landscape, positioning the architecture without alienating it from its surroundings. The use of wood and the form language embedded in the topography create a calm and natural atmosphere in harmony with its birdwatching function. The placement of observation areas at different levels enriches the user experience, while the addition of educational and exhibition spaces transforms the project from a mere viewing structure into a public learning space.

• While the organic form of the structure presents a strong idea, how the supporting system handles this sloping roof could be shown in more detail.
• The project could become more convincing if the technical details of the grass roof, such as maintenance, drainage, and waterproofing, were explained more clearly in the drawings.
• The impact of the openings used in the bird watching areas on sun control and interior comfort should be considered in more detail.
• How the structure is addressed in terms of disabled access is not clear; ramps and alternative circulation scenarios could be added.
• Although the interior organization is atmospherically successful, the relationship between the spaces could be made more legible in the plan.
• The year-round activity of the building could be supported by developing flexible usage scenarios for the education and exhibition areas.
• The project could be strengthened in terms of both safety and spatial experience if lighting strategies for the building's nighttime use were added.
• How the stairs leading to the roof are addressed in terms of safety and slip risk under heavy use could be detailed.
• Although the concept and atmosphere are quite successful in the drawings, strengthening the technical drawings in terms of scale, detail, and explanation could make the project appear more professional.

13.05.2026